
How to Compare Web Design Proposals Before You Pick a Designer
Two web design proposals can promise a five-page site and still describe very different projects. One may include writing the service pages, moving your old content, and training your team. The other may assume you’ll do all three. Before you compare prices, make sure you know what each proposal leaves on your plate.
Compare the work behind each page
Ask each designer to walk you through one important page, such as your main service page. Who decides what goes on it? Who writes the copy and selects the images? How many rounds of feedback are included, and what counts as a new request?
If you’re redesigning an existing site, ask which pages and forms will be moved, replaced, or retired. A proposal that says “content migration included” should specify which content and who checks it afterward.
Ask for a launch checklist you can understand
Choose a task a customer needs to complete and ask how the designer will test it. For a local business, that might mean opening the site on a phone, finding the right service, sending an inquiry, and confirming the message reaches the right person. For a redesign, ask who will check where your old page addresses lead after launch.
Check the costs and responsibilities after launch
Ask for a separate list of recurring costs and who pays them. Include hosting, paid tools, and any support plan the proposal assumes. Then ask which accounts you’ll control and whether you’ll receive a walkthrough of the changes you expect to make yourself.
Be specific about support. If a form stops sending messages the week after launch, who investigates? If you want a new service page two months later, what would be billed separately? Get both answers in writing.
Put each proposal on the same footing
Use the same five rows for each proposal and mark each item as included, optional, handled by your team, or unclear.
- Page design and development
- Copy, photography, and content migration
- Revisions and launch testing
- Account access, training, and handover
- Recurring costs and support
Turn unclear rows into questions before accepting a quote. If the proposals are hard to compare because the designers received different information, give each one the same one-page website design brief and ask for an updated scope.
Planning a new site or a redesign? Tell me about your website project. Share your existing URL if you have one and the most important thing you want the site to help customers do.


Permalink